Middlebury Homes with Traditional Style

Welcome to Middlebury, Indiana—a charming town nestled in the heart of Elkhart County, where the picturesque landscapes and warm community spirit create an inviting atmosphere for families and individuals alike. Known for its rich Amish heritage, Middlebury offers a unique blend of rural tranquility and modern conveniences, making it an ideal place to call home.

As you explore this delightful town, you’ll discover a variety of homes that embody traditional architectural styles, reflecting the timeless elegance that many buyers seek. These homes often feature classic elements such as gabled roofs, wide porches, and beautifully manicured lawns, creating a welcoming facade that invites you in. Inside, you’ll find spacious layouts, cozy living areas, and charming details that enhance the character of each residence.

Middlebury is not only a haven for those who appreciate traditional homes; it also boasts a vibrant community filled with local shops, delicious dining options, and recreational activities. The town hosts numerous events throughout the year, including farmers' markets and seasonal festivals, which foster a sense of belonging and connection among residents.

For nature lovers, the surrounding countryside offers breathtaking views and opportunities for outdoor adventures, from hiking and biking to fishing and picnicking. With its friendly atmosphere, rich history, and beautiful traditional homes, Middlebury is a place where you can truly feel at home. Whether you're looking to settle down or invest in a property, this quaint town promises a lifestyle that balances comfort, community, and charm. Come discover the magic of Middlebury, Indiana!

Newest Middlebury Homes with Traditional Style

$715,000

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 202631921 MLS ⋅ 3,333 SqFt.

Welcome to your private waterfront sanctuary on Forest Lakes Drive. Set on nearly 2 secluded acres at the end of a quiet Middlebury cul-de-sac, this exceptional 5-bedroom, 3.5-bath East Lake home offers direct water access to canoe, kayak, and fish right from your private dock. Enjoy stunning water views from multiple vantage points, including the bright and inviting 3-season room—an ideal spot to take in the morning sun. The home features 5 bedrooms and 3.5 bathrooms, highlighted by a main-floor primary suite complete with a walk-in closet and convenient main-floor laundry. The vaulted ceiling in the living room with a stone fireplace creates an open, airy feel, while the walkout basement expands your living space. As a bonus, there is and a sauna for ultimate relaxation. Step outside to your own backyard oasis featuring an in-ground pool, perfect for entertaining or unwinding in total privacy. Additional highlights include a 3-stall garage, storage shed, and major mechanical updates with a furnace and A/C just 3 years old and a roof approximately 8 years old. All of this in a prime location with close proximity to Shipshewana, Middlebury, and the Indiana Toll Road—making it easy to enjoy both peaceful lake living and convenient access to nearby amenities.

53660 Forest Lakes Dr, Middlebury

Listing courtesy of from R1 Property Group LLC.

$349,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 202631264 MLS ⋅ 1,908 SqFt.

Here's your chance to enjoy country living in Middlebury while still being in a desirable neighborhood! Situated on over half an acre, this beautifully maintained home offers the perfect blend of peaceful surroundings and modern convenience. From the moment you arrive, you'll appreciate the manicured lawn, welcoming covered front porch, basketball hoop, and the abundance of wildlife—including deer, bunnies, and birds—all while being just minutes from the charm of Amish Country. Step inside to an open-concept floor plan featuring fresh paint throughout, a spacious living area, and a kitchen designed for gathering with a center island, eat-in dining area, and main-level laundry complete with a utility sink. Upstairs, the primary suite offers a private bathroom and walk-in closet, along with two additional generously sized bedrooms and a second full bathroom. Don't overlook the partially finished basement, offering additional living space plus a fourth bedroom currently being used as a home office. One of the unfinished storage rooms is already pre-plumbed for an additional bathroom, providing an excellent opportunity to expand the home's living space and add future value. Step outside to the back patio overlooking the expansive backyard that rears up to Corson Riverwoods County Park. The backyard space is the perfect spot to relax, entertain, or simply enjoy the peaceful country setting. Built in 2021, this home is better than new, with thoughtful upgrades already completed, including a water softener, reverse osmosis R/O water system, new sump pump, and updated light fixtures. If you've been searching for a home that offers space, comfort, and the beauty of the countryside without sacrificing convenience, this is the one. Schedule your private showing today before this opportunity is gone!

54895 Moonfish Ct, Middlebury

Listing courtesy of from McKinnies Realty, LLC. Cell: 574-335-9022

$627,500

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 202626923 MLS ⋅ 2,571 SqFt.

**Lakefront on 3.67 Acres – Hunter Lake!** One-owner home in popular Middlebury schools. 4 bed, 2.5 bath with wood-burning fireplace in the family room. Appliances just 2 years old. Unfinished walk-out basement is a blank slate. Enjoy lake views from the private backyard, 12x20 porch, and screened lakeside gazebo. 24x30 barn with horse stalls. Lakefront + acreage + top schools — a rare find!

10416 State Road 120, Middlebury

Listing courtesy of from RE/MAX Results. Office: 574-533-9581

$800,000

5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 202629655 MLS ⋅ 4,908 SqFt.

OPEN HOUSE TOMORROW 1:00-3:00PM! Welcome to 13283 Cedar Creek Drive, where timeless design, impressive amenities, and exceptional comfort come together. The beautifully landscaped brick exterior leads into a bright and inviting interior highlighted by soaring vaulted ceilings, spacious living areas, and newer flooring throughout much of the home. Major improvements provide added comfort and peace of mind, including a newer roof, updated HVAC system, whole-home generator, and tankless water heater offering endless hot water. A central vacuum system adds another layer of everyday convenience. A dedicated home office provides a quiet place to work, while the exercise room offers flexible space for fitness or hobbies. The finished basement creates the ultimate entertainment retreat, complete with a projector and screen for memorable movie nights at home. Step outside and discover a private backyard with an inground pool, offering the perfect setting for summer gatherings, relaxing afternoons, and evenings spent outdoors. The hot tub may also be negotiated separately. Offering privacy, thoughtful updates, versatile living spaces, and an exceptional collection of amenities, this remarkable Middlebury home is designed for both comfortable everyday living and effortless entertaining.

13283 Cedar Creek Dr, Middlebury

Listing courtesy of from eXp Realty, LLC.

$1,200,000

6 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 202629033 MLS ⋅ 6,412 SqFt.

Welcome to this extraordinary custom all-brick estate nestled in the heart of Middlebury's prestigious Highland Woods subdivision. Perched atop the area's rolling hills, this exceptional Town & Country-built residence offers more than 6,000 square feet of beautifully finished living space and has been completely transformed with over $800,000 in luxurious updates completed within the past two years. Step inside the stunning foyer and discover impeccable craftsmanship and designer finishes throughout. The inviting lodge-inspired family room features a striking stone fireplace, while the spectacular custom kitchen is a true showpiece with premium finishes, abundant storage, and a hidden butler's pantry. The adjoining buffet and beverage area makes entertaining effortless, whether hosting holidays in the formal dining room or enjoying casual meals in the bright breakfast area overlooking your private back yard. You will love the spacious mudroom/laundry room. The perfect "drop spot" for coats, or backpacks. The main-level den/office with gorgeous custom woodwork provides the perfect work-from-home space. Upstairs, the luxurious primary suite features dual walk-in closets and a spa-inspired bath with a soaking tub and oversized tiled shower. Three additional bedrooms include a Jack-and-Jill bath with a walk-in shower and a third full bath with tub. The lower level is designed for entertaining with a custom kitchen, stone accents, a spacious family room with a second fireplace, bar area, two additional bedrooms, a fourth full bath, and a stunning wine room where fireside entertaining is at your fingertips for game nights, gatherings, or relaxing with friends. Outside, enjoy a private backyard surrounded by mature trees and abundant wildlife, along with a newly constructed deck ideal for outdoor living and entertaining. Beyond its beautiful finishes, this home offers peace of mind with new roof, windows, updated mechanicals, and a heated three-car attached garage. Every detail has been thoughtfully updated, and nothing has been overlooked. This is a rare opportunity to own one of Middlebury's finest homes.

205 Greenfield Dr, Middlebury

Listing courtesy of from Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group.

Start Your Search

IDX information is provided by the Indiana Regional MLS and is exclusively for the consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.

Last updated