Refine Search
Sort by
$158,000
3 Beds 1 Baths 202637504 MLS 960 SqFt. Susan Neal
Move-in ready 3-bedroom, 1-bath ranch offering a comfortable layout, nice updates, and a convenient location with easy access to I-70. The home features newer windows with a lifetime warranty, a newer HVAC system with approximately five years remaining on the warranty, fresh paint, and updated flooring throughout much of the home. The spacious living room offers plenty of natural light, while the eat-in kitchen provides ample cabinet and counter space and opens to the dining area with access to the large rear deck. All appliances remain with the sale, including the stove, refrigerator, washer, dryer, and water softener. Outside, enjoy a large deck with plenty of room for relaxing, grilling, or entertaining, along with a nice yard and an attached garage offering additional storage and workspace. With major updates already completed, appliances included, and a convenient location near town and I-70, this home is ready for its next owner to move in and enjoy.

544 E County Road 300 S, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Susan Neal from RE/MAX First Integrity. Office: 765-529-2211

$130,000
2 Beds 1 Baths 202637166 MLS 864 SqFt. Nathaniel Bennett
A private setting, an inviting front porch, and more space than you might expect—427 N. 20th St. is full of pleasant surprises. This 2-bedroom, 1-bath home sits on a generous .60-acre lot surrounded by mature trees, creating a peaceful setting with an impressive amount of privacy. Inside, the open floor plan gives the main living area a comfortable, connected feel that’s well suited for everyday living and entertaining. The partially finished basement is an uncommon bonus in a home of this style, offering valuable additional space with plenty of flexibility for a family room, home office, hobby area, or storage. Outside, the spacious front porch provides the perfect place to relax and enjoy the tree-lined surroundings. With its open layout, versatile basement, large lot, and secluded feel, 427 N. 20th St. offers a combination of comfort, space, and privacy that can be difficult to find.

427 N 20th St, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Nathaniel Bennett from F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate. Cell: 765-524-6306

$139,900
2 Beds 1 Baths 202635020 MLS 1,232 SqFt. Mike McKown
Welcome to 2232 Broad Street in New Castle, Indiana! This beautifully remodeled 2-bedroom, 1-bath home offers a wonderful blend of classic charm and modern updates. Step inside to find a warm and inviting layout featuring beautiful cabinetry, a comfortable living room and dining room, and a cozy fireplace that creates the perfect atmosphere for relaxing or entertaining. The nice-sized eat-in kitchen provides plenty of space for everyday meals and gatherings. The home also offers a full unfinished basement with laundry, including a washer and dryer, along with additional attic space that could potentially be finished to create even more living area and add valuable square footage. Outside, enjoy a private backyard and an enclosed front porch—an ideal spot to unwind and enjoy peaceful evenings. The enclosed porch is a great bonus space for morning coffee, reading, or relaxing with friends and family. The roof is older, but the seller is offering an excellent benefit: a new roof will be installed prior to closing.

2232 Broad St, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Mike McKown from F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate. Cell: 765-524-3018

$189,900
3 Beds 2 Baths 202634714 MLS 1,664 SqFt. Susan Neal
Completely remodeled two-story home offering the best of both worlds—the charm and character of an older home with the comfort and peace of mind of extensive modern updates. This 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath home features spacious rooms throughout, including a large kitchen with double ovens and all-new appliances including washer and dryer that remain with the sale. The inviting living room features an electric fireplace that stays, while the dining room showcases beautiful built-ins that preserve the home’s original character. Major improvements include a new roof, plumbing, HVAC, electrical wiring, and windows, making this home truly move-in ready. A large basement provides plenty of additional storage space. Outside, enjoy a spacious covered porch, sidewalks, off-street parking, and a detached 1.5-car garage. With its original bones and timeless details paired with nearly everything new, this home offers the character of an older property without the worry of outdated major systems.

607 S 18th St, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Susan Neal from RE/MAX First Integrity. Office: 765-529-2211

$369,900
4 Beds 2 Baths 202634558 MLS 2,192 SqFt. Susan Neal
Don't miss the opportunity to own this newer, beautifully maintained home situated on just over an acre. With four bedrooms, two full baths, an open-concept design, and plenty of indoor and outdoor living space, this home has so much to offer. A welcoming entry opens into the spacious great room with vaulted ceiling, where the truly open floor plan and abundance of windows create a bright and inviting atmosphere. The kitchen is designed for both everyday living and entertaining, featuring beautiful solid-surface countertops, ample cabinetry and counter space, and a large center island with sink. All appliances remain with the sale, including a newer dishwasher. The spacious primary suite features a private bath and an impressive walk-in closet. Three additional bedrooms provide plenty of space for family, guests, or a home office. A separate laundry and utility room adds everyday convenience. Outside, enjoy the privacy and space of the beautiful backyard from the covered back patio, or relax and watch the sunset from the large covered front porch. With just over an acre, there is plenty of room to enjoy the outdoors. A 2-car attached garage and separate detached garage provide excellent parking, storage, and workspace. Additional updates and features include a new central air unit and security system. With its newer construction, generous lot, versatile living spaces, and abundant storage, this move-in-ready home is one you won't want to miss.

900 S County Road 250 E, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Susan Neal from RE/MAX First Integrity. Office: 765-529-2211

$228,000
3 Beds 1 Baths 202633496 MLS 2,100 SqFt. Taylor Burkhart
Welcome to this charming 1.5-story home offering peaceful country-style living on nearly an acre, conveniently located 5 miles from Rochester and Lake Manitou, and just 5.5 miles from Akron. With 3 bedrooms and 1 full bath, this home offers plenty of flexible living space, including a living room, dining room, family room, kitchen, and bonus room that could easily serve as an additional bedroom, recreation room, or flex space. The updated full bathroom features a spacious walk-in shower, while the main-floor laundry room offers added convenience, including two built-in closets for ample storage. Outside, you’ll find plenty of parking with a carport on one side of the home and an additional open driveway on the other. The property also includes a versatile outbuilding that can be used as a two-vehicle garage, workshop, or additional storage space. Enjoy peace of mind knowing a metal roof was added in October 2025. When it’s time to unwind, relax on the covered front porch or step out onto the back deck overlooking the spacious yard—perfect for enjoying the peaceful surroundings and outdoor space this property has to offer. If you’re looking for the space and tranquility of country living without sacrificing convenience, this property is worth a look!

6192 E State Road 14th Hwy, Rochester

Listing courtesy of Taylor Burkhart from Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group. Cell: 574-268-8107

$184,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 202634358 MLS 1,843 SqFt. Lora Loveless
Duplex or Single Family Home with Endless Possibilities in Sunnyside Spacious single-family home or an investment opportunity, the possibilities are endless! This versatile duplex in the desirable Sunnyside area features two separate living units, making it an excellent opportunity for investors, owner-occupants, or anyone looking for flexibility. The first unit offers 3 bedrooms and 1 full bathroom, while the second unit features 1 bedroom and 1½ bathrooms. The property could be rented as two separate units to generate rental income, or you could live in one unit while renting the other to help offset your monthly expenses. For buyers looking for a larger single-family residence, the property also offers the potential to convert back to a single-family home, creating an opportunity for a spacious residence with plenty of room to customize and make your own. Come see the possibilities and envision what this property could become!

1930-1932 Fairmont Ave, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Lora Loveless from F.C. Tucker/Crossroads Real Estate. Cell: 765-760-2444

$199,900
4 Beds 2 Baths 202633878 MLS 1,750 SqFt. Brittany Cavanaugh-Stults
Welcome to a beautifully refreshed two-story home in the heart of New Castle! This 1,750 sq ft residence sits on a 3,920 sq ft lot and blends classic charm with a host of modern updates for true move-in-ready comfort. Step inside to refinished hardwood floors, plush new carpeting upstairs, and fresh paint throughout. The living room, anchored by a cozy fireplace, flows into the dining area and kitchen—perfect for gatherings. The kitchen, pantry, and bathrooms all feature brand new flooring, while the kitchen boasts a new sink for added style and functionality. Enjoy peace of mind with new PEX plumbing, new toilets, updated smoke alarms, a CO2 sensor, and all new light switches and outlets. The home is brightened by newer vinyl windows and stylish new light fixtures. Fresh landscaping and a privacy-fenced backyard add curb appeal and outdoor enjoyment, while a new exterior door on the back of the house and garage enhances security and convenience. The flexible layout offers three bedrooms upstairs and a fourth bedroom on the main level—ideal for guests or a home office. A partial, unfinished basement provides ample storage or future expansion potential. The detached one-car garage is perfect for parking or projects. Bonus: The seller is providing a one-year home warranty for added peace of mind! This is a rare opportunity to own a move-in-ready home with thoughtful updates and classic appeal. Want to know about nearby businesses or community highlights? Just ask!

214 S 8th St, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Brittany Cavanaugh-Stults from Epique Inc.. Cell: 765-465-1922

$143,000
3 Beds 1 Baths 202632060 MLS 1,101 SqFt. Michael Meredith
Welcome home to this inviting 3-bedroom ranch featuring a bright, open-concept layout designed for comfortable everyday living and effortless entertaining. The spacious floor plan offers excellent flow from room to room, creating an airy atmosphere filled with natural light. The versatile third bedroom can easily serve as a traditional bedroom, home office, or flexible bonus space to fit your lifestyle. Enjoy peace of mind with major mechanical updates, including a new furnace (2024), new central air conditioning (2024), and a new water heater (2025). This home also features a 2-car garage and a fenced-in front yard! Don’t miss the opportunity to own this move-in-ready home offering comfort, convenience, and modern updates.

713 N 27th St, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Michael Meredith from NextHome Elite Real Estate. Cell: 812-720-1645

$279,900
3 Beds 2 Baths 202631800 MLS 1,528 SqFt. Krista Gibson
1996 W Railroad Street sits at the end of the road on a full acre, lined by hole 12 of Westwood Golf Course and just seconds from Westwood Elementary. It feels like a private retreat you wouldn’t expect to find there, which is part of what makes it so memorable. Inside, you’ll find three bedrooms, two full baths, engineered hardwood through the kitchen and dining area, and a transom above the entry into the living room that adds another layer of character. And there is plenty of it here. Nothing feels cookie-cutter or overly polished into submission. Outside, the covered porch gives you a front-row seat to slower mornings, while the private backyard offers an open deck, gazebo, mature landscaping, and a small koi pond. It is the kind of yard where you sit down for five minutes and suddenly realize an hour has passed. The detached two-car garage includes workshop space, additional storage, and a lean-to that makes an easy potting station for flowers, plants, and whatever gardening project you decide to start next. This property is peaceful, unique, full of personality, and honestly, the kind of place you may never want to leave.

1996 W Railroad St, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Krista Gibson from RE/MAX First Integrity. Cell: 765-524-4013

$179,900
3 Beds 1 Baths 202631520 MLS 1,694 SqFt. Melissa Guffy-Griffin
Stunningly updated 3-bedroom traditional home featuring a spacious, fully remodeled kitchen which is the heart of the home. The open concept kitchen dining combo flows perfectly onto a massive deck that is great for year round gatherings in the private backyard that offers seclusion to relax and play. Main floor laundry, and a full size dry basement providing extra area for storage, a workshop, game room, or crafting - this traditional home blends classic character with modern touches and everyday functionality. Centrally located within walking distance to stores, schools, and parks which make it in even more appealing. Comfort, convenience, and a home that works for real life. Incredible value for a move in ready, turn-key home that also features a brand new central air unit installed this year! Come take a look and imagine the possibilities to make this space your own.

2205 S 14th St, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Melissa Guffy-Griffin from RE/MAX First Integrity. Office: 765-529-2211

$84,900
2 Beds 1 Baths 202628335 MLS 1,120 SqFt. Donna Showalter
Welcome home to this charming 2-bedroom, 1-bath property that's ready for its next owner! Step inside to a nice-sized living room that offers plenty of space to relax or entertain. The eat-in kitchen provides a cozy spot for family meals and everyday living. Enjoy peace of mind knowing the furnace and central air are less than one year old, while the water heater is only three years old, giving you valuable updates already taken care of. Outside, you'll love spending time on the covered front porch, perfect for enjoying your morning coffee or unwinding in the evening. The partially fenced yard offers space for pets, gardening, or outdoor activities, and the 1½-car garage provides extra room for parking and storage.

2205 Plum St, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Donna Showalter from Legacy Real Estate Partners Inc. Cell: 765-545-0463

$109,900
3 Beds 1 Baths 202618175 MLS 880 SqFt. Bryce Conyers
Welcome Home! This one story home offers 3 bedrooms, 1 full bath, and 880 square feet of living space. A covered front porch leads into the main living area, which flows into the dining area and kitchen for a practical and functional layout. The hallway provides convenient access to all three bedrooms and the full bathroom. The home features vinyl siding, vinyl replacement windows, a newer asphalt roof, gutters, and downspouts for low-maintenance exterior living. Additional updates include replacement insulation and an updated electrical box completed in 2022. Outside, the fenced backyard offers space for pets, gardening, or relaxing outdoors. A detached 1-car garage provides additional storage, workshop space, or covered parking. Conveniently located near local shopping and amenities, this move-in ready property also offers an opportunity for future updates and personalization.

2434 Plum St, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Bryce Conyers from Starr Real Estate LLC.

$349,900
4 Beds 2 Baths 202625772 MLS 3,336 SqFt. Susan Neal
Welcome home to the space, comfort, and flexibility you've been searching for! Situated on almost an acre in town, this move-in ready home offers an incredible amount of living space rarely found in today's market. Combining modern updates with versatile living areas and a peaceful wooded setting with a creek running along the property line, this property truly has something for everyone. Step inside to discover an oversized living room featuring beautiful hardwood floors and a fireplace, creating the perfect space for relaxing or entertaining. The completely renovated kitchen is the heart of the home, offering abundant cabinetry, generous counter space, brand-new appliances, under-cabinet lighting, and a functional layout designed for both everyday living and hosting family and friends. The main level features two spacious bedrooms and two large full bathrooms, one has been recently remodeled, providing convenient one-level living. Upstairs you'll find two additional rooms that could serve as bedrooms, guest rooms, office space, or bonus rooms. In addition to the living room, you'll enjoy multiple gathering spaces, including a comfortable family room, a dining area with a soaring vaulted ceiling, and an additional expansive great room with vaulted ceilings and patio doors leading to the backyard. Whether you need space for entertaining, a home office, playroom, or hobbies, this home offers the flexibility to fit your lifestyle. Additional highlights include a two-car attached garage, separate utility room, abundant parking, beautiful hardwood floors, updated finishes throughout, and an excellent location close to schools (walk to all three schools!) with quick access to State Road 3 and Interstate 70, making commuting a breeze.

410 Crescent Dr, New Castle

Listing courtesy of Susan Neal from RE/MAX First Integrity. Office: 765-529-2211

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker of MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some listings have been excluded from this website.