Jefferson Homes with Petersburg Elementary School

Welcome to Jefferson Township, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Pike County, Indiana. This charming township, located just outside the quaint city of Otwell, offers a serene lifestyle combined with a strong sense of community. Known for its picturesque landscapes and friendly atmosphere, Jefferson Township is the perfect place for families, retirees, and anyone looking to enjoy the beauty of rural living.

One of the standout features of this area is its proximity to Petersburg Elementary School, which is a significant draw for families seeking quality education for their children. The school is known for its dedicated staff and nurturing environment, making it an ideal setting for young learners to thrive. Living in Jefferson Township means you’re just a stone's throw away from this educational institution, ensuring that your children have easy access to a top-notch education.

The homes in Jefferson Township reflect the warmth and charm of the community. From cozy single-family residences to spacious properties with sprawling yards, there’s a diverse selection to suit various lifestyles and budgets. Many homes feature modern amenities while retaining that classic Indiana charm, providing the perfect backdrop for creating lasting memories.

In addition to the inviting homes and excellent school options, Jefferson Township offers a peaceful lifestyle with plenty of outdoor activities. Enjoy leisurely walks in nature, local parks, and community events that foster connections among neighbors. If you’re seeking a place where you can truly feel at home, Jefferson Township is waiting for you to discover its unique allure. Embrace the tranquility and charm of this delightful community today!

Newest Jefferson Homes with Petersburg Elementary School

$185,000

202635547 MLS ⋅ Briar Meadors

Located in Otwell, Pike County, Indiana, this +/-9-acre tract is a rare find for the area: Open, buildable ground with paved highway frontage, two-sided access, no area zoning, and in proximity to a full slate of utilities. The property was formerly part of the Otwell Elementary School grounds, giving it a level, cleared site with an established presence right along State Road 257! Utility access is the standout feature here. Sewer, water, two electric providers, and internet services are all available nearby, a combination that's hard to find on open acreage in this part of southern Indiana. Paired with the level, open ground, it's a strong fit for residential, commercial, or other development projects. Otwell sees steady commuter traffic passing through daily, and its central location between larger cities positions it for growth as nearby housing demand increases. Jasper is about 10 miles away; Petersburg (the Pike County seat) is about 11 miles away; Washington is about 17 miles away; and Evansville is about 58 miles away, putting the property within reach of larger-area amenities and employment centers. Otwell Sewer & Water provided maps of the current service infrastructure, which are available for buyer review. Whether the plan is a 55+ community, a duplex neighborhood, single-family homes, townhomes, or a new commercial build, the nearby utilities and its geographic location make this +/-9-acre tract appealing and ready for its next owner!

at 1869 At 1869 N Sr 257, Otwell

Listing courtesy of Briar Meadors from Whitetail Properties Real Estate. cell: 812-354-4542

$390,000

16 Beds ⋅ 12 Baths ⋅ 202635486 MLS ⋅ 42,079 SqFt. ⋅ Briar Meadors

Located at 1869 N SR 257 in Otwell, Pike County, Indiana, this former Otwell Elementary School building is offered for sale on +/-10.79 acres. It is a rare renovation opportunity: +/-42,079 square feet under roof, built in 1973 with a 2001 addition featuring two-sided access, offered with complete building plans for the entire structure, included in the sale! The floor plan offers room for reinvention. Sixteen classrooms arranged in a rectangular layout provide a buyer with a wide range of flexible space to reconfigure, alongside a front office, library, kitchen, and stage. The combined gym and cafeteria is approximately 8,000 square feet of open, high-ceilinged space. Absent area zoning, the building holds potential to be redeveloped to fit your needs! Whether it be apartment residential housing, office space, an assisted living home, or a company's new headquarters and assembly facility! Multiple entrances and blacktop parking front and rear support a range of new uses, from multi-tenant to single-user. The building is all-slab construction with 10 total bathrooms throughout: one in the kitchen, one in the front office, one in each of two kindergarten classrooms, two in the teacher workroom, one in the nurse's office, and another by the center auditorium. The girls' and boys' locker rooms are both connected to the gym, which also has showers. Mechanically, the building includes 3 boilers believed to work, 2 chiller units, and 4 air handlers, existing infrastructure that a renovation can build on. Per the seller, one AC unit has a bad main computer, and the other has a hole in its tank, both of which are repairable. The kitchen walk-in cooler has worked before, but needs recharging. An elevator lift to the cafeteria stage and the fire alarm system are both believed to work. WIN Energy supplies power to the main building from the west, while the sign near SR 257 is powered separately by Dubois REC. Otwell Sewer & Water also services the building. The basketball and tennis courts await renovation. Otwell is a small Pike County community with an abundance of daily commuter traffic. Jasper is +/-10 miles away, Petersburg is +/-11 miles away, Washington is +/-17 miles away, and Evansville is +/-58 miles away, placing the property within reach of larger regional amenities and employment centers. Sold as-is, with complete building plans provided, this large-footprint building is ready for a buyer with vision to give it new life.

1869 N Sr 257, Otwell

Listing courtesy of Briar Meadors from Whitetail Properties Real Estate. cell: 812-354-4542

$134,700

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 202622285 MLS ⋅ 1,168 SqFt. ⋅ Hannah Welsh

This 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom home offers a fantastic opportunity for homeowners and investors alike. Whether you're looking for a comfortable primary residence or a property to add to your rental portfolio, this home provides plenty of potential to make it your own. Recent updates include a fully remodeled bathroom featuring a new shower, vanity, and improved layout that maximizes closet and storage space. The home also boasts updated vinyl flooring, creating a clean, modern look. The seller also installed a tankless water heater, providing added efficiency and convenience. The kitchen offers an abundance of cabinet and countertop space, making meal preparation, storage, and entertaining a breeze. With its functional layout and ample workspace, the kitchen serves as the heart of the home. With its split floor plan and room for personalization, this property is ready for its next owner to add their own finishing touches. Don't miss the chance to make this versatile home your own!

9845 E Jackson St, Otwell

Listing courtesy of Hannah Welsh from SELL4FREE-WELSH REALTY CORPORATION. andy.welshs4f@gmail.com

$474,900

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 202611899 MLS ⋅ 4,160 SqFt. ⋅ Adam Boyd

Set on nearly five acres of open, usable land, this home delivers space, freedom, and versatility in every direction. Built in 2000 and thoughtfully expanded, it spans more than 4,100 square feet across the main and upper levels plus a partially finished basement that gives you even more room to live, play, or entertain. Step inside and feel the scale. The main floor flows naturally from a welcoming dining and living room area. The kitchen is fitted with white cabinetry, a beautiful range hood, and an island designed for casual breakfasts or late-night conversations. Vinyl flooring and carpeting define the main level, keeping things stylish and comfortable. The laundry and half bath sit conveniently off the kitchen, leading into a huge bonus suite over the garage, complete with a walk-in closet, ideal as a bedroom, or game room. The primary suite is a statement of its own: spacious, calm, and complete with a large walk-in closet and bathroom featuring tile flooring, a garden jacuzzi tub, and a separate shower. Upstairs, two more oversized bedrooms, each with walk-in closets. They share a full bath between them. Downstairs, the partially finished basement adds even more potential. Drywalled walls, carpet, a unique brick-built shower, and a wood-burning stove bring both comfort and character. There’s also an additional framed-in room ready for your imagination. Outside, everything comes together for true country living. The front porch invites you to slow down, while the massive back porch is made for gatherings and takes full advantage of the views and wide-open land. The home’s exterior features vinyl siding and a roof installed recently. The main and upstairs areas are serviced by their own HVAC system, which includes a updated unit in the upstairs. For the hobbyist, entrepreneur, or collectors, two incredible pole barns take this property to another level—one measuring 30x74, the other 30x40, both with concrete floors. The 30x40 barn even includes dual 12x40 lean-tos on each side, giving you all the covered storage you could ask for. With a deep 32x30 2 car attached garage, expansive interiors, and multiple outbuildings, this property balances functionality, comfort, and opportunity. It’s not just a home—it’s a lifestyle waiting to be lived.

6381 E Co Rd 450 N, Otwell

Listing courtesy of Adam Boyd from BOYD REALTY & DEVELOPMENT LLC.

Start Your Search

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker of MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some listings have been excluded from this website.